Top 10 Best Baby Crib Mattresses in 2023 Reviews
Last updated on January 13, 2023
Babies sleep for long periods, and it makes sense investing in a quality baby crib mattress. When choosing a baby crib mattress, comfort and safety must top in your list of priority. We all want the best for our babies and taking time to choose the best baby crib mattress is highly advised. The baby’s sleep is quite crucial for their growth. It is said that babies grow when they are asleep. Most infants sleep somewhere between 14-17 hours a day. This goes to show the importance of choosing a high-quality crib mattress.
The federal government does regulate the thickness and size of baby crib mattresses on the market. However, this does not mean you go all out and buy just any baby crib mattress. There are several options to consider before choosing the right one for your baby. In this reviews, we narrow down your choices for the best baby crib mattresses to just ten. We are helping you choose the most comfortable and safest baby crib mattresses on the market.
Make sure you read our reviews below before choosing a mattress that best suits your little one.
Table of Contents
- 10. Milliard Crib Mattress, Dual Comfort System
- 9. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress
- 8. Milliard Memory Foam Crib Mattress
- 7. My First Crib Mattress
- 6. Sealy Baby Firm Rest Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress
- 5. Newton Baby Crib Mattress And Toddler Bed
- 4. Delta Children Twinkle Stars Fiber Core Crib and Toddler Mattress
- 3. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Blue Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress
- 2. LA Baby 3-Inch Portable/Mini Crib Mattress with Soy Foam
- 1. Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress
10. Milliard Crib Mattress, Dual Comfort System
The Milliard crib mattress is one of the best choices to start our list. It is a dual sided mattress with a soft side for toddlers and a firmer side for an infant. This mattress features a supportive foam layer that cradles the baby for maximum comfort. The supportive foam layers give proper baby posture for the baby’s back and neck. You can be sure your baby is sleeping soundly in the best conditions possible. The mattress cover is 100 percent cotton for added convenience. It is highly soft and breathable for excellent airflow. Overall, this is a standard size baby crib mattress measuring 52 by 27.5 by 5.5 inches. It fits most standard toddler beds and baby cribs. It is tested and meets or exceeds most safety regulations and certifications.
Pros
- Two sides of soft and firm for toddlers and infants
- Waterproof and washable cotton cover
- Breathable cover
- Supportive foam layers
Cons
- Needs cover flipping for infant use
9. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress
The Little Dreamer is a dual sided mattress with a two-stage sleep system for infants and toddlers. It is an eco-friendly plant-based foam layer. The mattress features a soft-sided side for the toddler and a firm side for the infant. It is a quality crib mattress made of medical grade quality fabric. The mattress is waterproof and will prevent any spills or leakage from getting to the foam. It cleans easily allowing for easy maintenance. The materials used are hypoallergenic and friendly to the baby. Overall, this mattress is an excellent quality resistant to bed bugs, mites and dust. Your baby can sleep soundly. It is tested to meet the highest standards and comes fully certified for safety and performance.
Pros
- Medical grade fabric
- Waterproof
- Resistant to rust, bed bugs and mite
- Dual-sided for toddler and infants
Cons
- A bit pricey
8. Milliard Memory Foam Crib Mattress
This is by far the best baby crib mattress with a firmer foam base for maximum baby support. It is a quality mattress featuring top-quality foam. The mattress construction combines excellent comfort, durability, support and luxury. It is a great choice with hundreds of positive reviews online. The mattress features hypoallergenic certified foam. The foam resists mold, allergens, dust mites and bacteria making it a safe choice for the baby. It also comes with a removable and machine washable bamboo cover. Overall, this is a quality memory foam crib mattress that will not lose shape over the years.
Pros
- Standard size to fit most baby cribs snugly
- Removable and machine washable bamboo cover
- Hypoallergenic and certified foam
- It is firm and retains shape over time
Cons
- Not 100 percent waterproof
7. My First Crib Mattress
This is a standard baby crib mattress measuring 51-5/8 by 27-1/4 by 5 inches. It is a great fit for all baby cribs and comes with everything you need. The mattress features a removable cover for easy cleaning and maintenance. The cover is pretty soft, washable and waterproof to prevent spills and leakages damaging your mattress. It is a quality crib mattress made of the CertiPUR-US certified polyurethane foam. It meets or exceeds most CPSC flammability standards. This is a safe crib mattress to buy for your little one with confidence. The crib mattress is mite-proof, lead-free and anti-microbial resistant. It comes machine rolled and compressed in a single box for easy delivery without affecting performances.
Pros
- Made without any ozone depleters
- Hypoallergenic
- Removable waterproof cover
- Square corners for a snug fit
Cons
- Not so deep
6. Sealy Baby Firm Rest Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress
This is an advanced baby crib mattress with 204 high coil counts. The heat tempered coils are interwoven to provide superior firmness and excellent posture support. This is a well-made mattress with all-around borders to keep edges, sides and corners of the mattress firm. The baby weight is well distributed through the anti-sag system prevent any hot spots when the baby is sweating. It also features a quality hospital grade cover. The cover is highly durable, breathable and cleans easily. Overall, this is a premium quality baby crib mattress with a steel edge design. It is quite comfortable and supportive. It is made in the USA to the highest standards and passes all necessary safety standards.
Pros
- Waterproof
- Superior firmness and support
- Quite comfortable
- High-quality foam
Cons
- A bit pricey
5. Newton Baby Crib Mattress And Toddler Bed
The Newton is one of the safest baby crib mattresses out there with a new breathe-Thru Technology. It is a quality mattress that allows for free airflow reducing any suffocation risks. You don’t have to worry about your baby breathing even when rolling over at night. The mattress also regulates temperature preventing any form of overheating. It easily eliminates sweaty backs and ensures your baby sleeps soundly. This is a long-lasting and durable mattress with a dual-stage design for use by toddlers and infants. It is also hypoallergenic and highly recommended by pediatricians. It has won numerous awards and can be the best choice for the healthy growth of your baby.
Pros
- Highly breathable
- Durable and long-lasting]
- A two-stage design for use by toddlers and infants
- Temperature regulating
Cons
- A slight chemical smell in the first few days of use
4. Delta Children Twinkle Stars Fiber Core Crib and Toddler Mattress
The Delta baby crib mattress is a firm thermo-bonded choice for excellent firmness. It is a lightweight design mattress with square corners for easy fitting. The mattress is quite easy to use. It allows for easy changing of the sheets. It is a perfect size fitting most standard cribs with a snug fit. The construction of this mattress is quite safe meeting and exceeding the safest standards. There are no toxic fire retardants, lead or phthalate. It is also waterproof ensuring there are no water leakages. Overall, this is a pretty decent baby crib mattress with a massive 7-year limited warranty. It is also made in the USA to the highest standards.
Pros
- Lightweight for easy changing
- Great thermo polyester bonding
- Square corners for a snug fit
- Meets or exceeds flammability standards
Cons
- Develops indentation marks with time
3. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Blue Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress
This is one of the finest baby crib mattresses to buy this year. It was the winner for the 2017 Women’s Choice Award and remains one of the most recommended baby crib mattresses. The construction of the mattress features the high-density thermo-bonding for maximum firmness and support. It is sturdily made of the durable polyester fibers and will last you for long. This mattress is lead and phthalate free. It is also hypoallergenic making it quite safe for babies. The vinyl cover is resistant to stains, odors and water. It also wipes clean allowing for easy maintenance. Overall, this is a lightweight and durable design mattress fitting most cribs and toddler beds. It can hold a maximum 50lbs.
Pros
- High-density thermo bonded core
- 100 percent waterproof and stain-resistant vinyl outer cover
- Lightweight
- Durable
Cons
- The cover produces noise
2. LA Baby 3-Inch Portable/Mini Crib Mattress with Soy Foam
The LA baby crib mattress is a 3-inch thick mattress with a soy foam core. This is a hypoallergenic mattress with a blended cotton cover to feel soft on the baby. It is a friendly mattress that will not make your baby sneeze. The mattress features a dust mite barrier keeping the mattress in great shape. It comes with a waterproof back and is quite easy to clean. There are no phthalates or lead metal making it safe for the baby. The box-edge construction ensures a firm and snug fit. Overall, this is a highly breathable mattress with a blended cotton fire barrier. It is an eco-friendly option that will offer your baby maximum support and comfort when sleeping. It is proudly made in the USA and comes with a three years warranty.
Pros
- Dust mite barrier
- Box-edge construction for a secure fit
- Highly breathable
- Eco-friendly with soy foam core
Cons
- A bit small
The Graco baby crib mattress is our final choice on the list and an excellent one with a breathable foam and water-resistant cover. It is a premium quality mattress with excellent reviews online. The breathable foam ensures your baby sleeps soundly with maximum airflow. The materials used are anti-microbial and anti-static free of lead and phthalates. It is a quality choice meeting all the federal flammability regulations. It is designed for comfort with a thick 5-inch foam and a water-resistant lining. You will not worry about water leakages and spills anymore. Overall, this is a complete bedroom solution for your little one with everything you needs.
Pros
- Anti-static and anti-microbial materials
- Water-resistant lining
- Thick 5-inch foam
- Meets all safety standards
Cons
- A bit heavy
Conclusion
These are the best baby crib mattresses on the market currently for maximum comfort and safety for infants and toddlers. The mattresses are highly rated and recommended for baby’s use. They are soft, breathable and made of baby-friendly materials. They don’t have any bad odor and will be a great addition to any home with infants. Go right ahead and choose one that best suits your baby’s sleeping needs.